I've been listening to the new Strokes' album a lot lately. I really dig The Strokes. I probably listen to them more than anyone, even Dylan, and the new album seems to be on par with their previous two efforts. But I do have one big problem with it; it's too long.
Not too long, time-wise, but too long amount-of-song-wise. It has 14 songs. That's just too many songs for me to really wrap my brain around. I prefer 8 or 10 songs.
The best albums are the ones that you can wholly grasp; and in order to have this complete understanding, I really need 8 or 10 songs. Under 8 is too little, then it's like an EP. Over 10 is too much, too big a statement. And 9 doesn't work because it's an odd number; the ideal album has two equal sides, which demands evenness.
12 songs is tolerable, but it has too be absolutely supreme. Substance, by New Order, is the only 12 song album I've ever been able to fully grasp. 6 songs on each side with a nice, natural linear progression, all held together by a very unique style. But, in general, I dislike 12 songs on an album.
Born to Run and Astral Weeks, two of the ten greatest albums ever, both have 8 songs. Perfect. Absolutely flawless. Every song a masterpiece. Joshua Tree; almost perfect. 11 songs. But see, if we got rid of Bullet the Blue Sky, we'd have a 10 song masterpiece, just like Beggar's Banquet.
There are of course, exceptions. For instance, the occasional, but extremely rare, sprawling double-album masterpiece; London Calling, Exile on Main Street; Paul's Boutique (actually, only a single album, but why get all precise?) Yet these are highly uncommon, and I don't recommend that anyone, except the fully confident rock band, should even attempt it.
There's also the occasional misleading exception. Abbey Road has a whopping 17 songs. Usually, that'd be enough to send me on to the next torrent. But it's tricky, cuz 8 of the songs are from a single medley, thereby putting the actual total of the songs at an ideal 10. Genius. Sgt Pepper's, on the other hand, has an ungodly 13 songs (long, odd and unlucky.) But Sgt Pepper's is extremely overrated; it's quite sub-par; now we know why.
I've actually considered going through all my albums and deleting extra baggage to make them all 8 or 10 songs, max. But that seems a little obsessive-compulsive, doesn't it?






Recent Comments